Vystopia: Measuring The Emotional Toll Of Being Vegan
Depression and anxiety became more common after the COVID-19 pandemic. Another source of mental strain is compassion fatigue, which is generally defined as mental exhaustion that arises from a weakened ability to handle the suffering of others. Considerable research has focused on compassion fatigue in caregiving, but compassion fatigue in animal-related environments is also beginning to garner attention.
Although individuals working in animal rescue and similar fields are vulnerable to compassion fatigue, one need not work directly with animals to experience it. Vegetarians, vegans, and animal rights activists have described the mental and emotional toll animal suffering in agriculture has taken on them. Since reminders of animal exploitation through agriculture can be as commonplace as the meat section in a supermarket, this study’s researchers propose that constant reminders of animal suffering, and the empathy it elicits in vegans, may be a risk factor for negative emotions.
Australian psychologist and author Clare Mann coined the term “vystopia,” a blend of “vegan” and “dystopia,” to describe this phenomenon. Based on her clinical work with vegans, Mann proposed eight symptoms:
- Alienation in connecting with non-vegans.
- Misanthropy toward those who continue to consume animal products.
- Guilt over previously consuming animal products.
- Guilt over not doing enough to protect animals.
- Inability to enjoy everyday life due to the awareness of animal suffering.
- Frustration with non-vegans who show little interest in animal welfare.
- Anger over being burdened with the knowledge of animal abuse.
- Powerlessness and invalidation when health professionals dismiss vegan concerns.
Building A Way To Measure Vystopia
As vystopia is a fairly recent term, researchers sought to find a way to measure the concept. To do this, researchers grouped the symptoms set forth by Mann into four dimensions: anger, guilt, alienation, and distress.
The researchers then split their sample in half at random. They used exploratory factor analysis to see how the items clustered in one half, then confirmatory factor analysis to check that structure in the other half. They also tested whether the scale worked the same way for men and women. Lastly, they predicted that vystopia would correlate with animal rights motives, solidarity with animals, anger, shame, loneliness, and depression.
The researchers recruited 1,027 English-speaking, self-identified vegans from the U.S., Canada, and the E.U. through the survey platform Prolific. After removing 30 who failed attention checks, 997 remained. A virtually equal number of men (48%) and women (47%) participated, along with nonbinary participants (5%). Most (84%) of the participants were white, with 5% identifying as Hispanic, 4% as Black, 3% as Asian, only 0.2% as Native American, and 4% as other.
Participants for the study were presented with 32 items, each beginning with “I feel…” followed by an emotion word, such as “outrage” or “distress,” and a statement about how animals are treated. These items were rated on a 5-point Likert scale, from 1 (never) to 5 (constantly). Each of the four hypothesized dimensions had eight items. For example, the item using “outrage” fell under the anger dimension.
What The Researchers Found
The four dimensions didn’t hold up. A single factor explained most of the shared variation in the items (almost 53%), and several items didn’t clearly belong to their intended dimension. Participants who scored high on one set of items tended to score high on the others, so the researchers treated vystopia as one construct instead of four.
Researchers then created an eight-item scale using two items from each of the four original dimensions, to keep the scale’s coverage broad. The final scale held together well as a single measure and worked the same way for men and women. The researchers then checked how scores related to the other measures in the survey.
People who scored higher on vystopia also tended to report stronger solidarity with animals and stronger animal rights motives for their diet. These were the strongest correlations. Higher scores also went along with more anger and depression, and to a lesser degree with internal shame and loneliness. The relationship between age and vystopia wasn’t statistically significant. Women reported higher levels of vystopia than men, with average scores of 3.34 and 2.89 on a scale from 1 to 5.
What The Study Can’t Tell Us
The researchers noted that separate dimensions of vystopia could still exist that their design, items, or sample couldn’t detect. The study was also correlational and relied on a single self-reported survey, so it can’t show whether vystopia leads to depression or loneliness, or the reverse. And because it included only vegans, it can’t say whether vegans score higher than anyone else. The sample also lacked diversity: 84% of participants were white. The authors call for future studies in cultures with different relationships to animals and veganism.
What This Means For Advocates
Vystopia names a kind of distress that many vegans may recognize but that researchers haven’t had a way to measure. Further exploring this topic may eventually lead to greater awareness, and in turn better mental health resources, for vegans and the advocates who work alongside them. For advocacy groups, the link with loneliness suggests that community and peer support may be worth offering to vegans who feel this distress, though the study didn’t test whether support reduces it.
https://doi.org/10.1163/15685306-bja10310

