Faunalytics.org makes use of JavaScript to operate fully, but Javascript is disabled in your browser
Photo by Pixabay user evalangrova
vizsla lying indoors on a wooden floor

United States V. Stevens: Win, Loss, Or Draw For Animals?

Summary By: | Published: April 18, 2014
Estimated Reading Time: < 1 minute
download report PDFLog in or sign up for access
FavoriteLoadingSave to My Library
FULL TEXT The full text of this article is available
PEER REVIEWED This article has been peer reviewed
EXTERNAL STUDY This is a summary of an external study
The core issue of whether animal protection can override free speech rights was positively impacted by this new judgement.

In 1999, a law against depictions of animal cruelty was enacted to criminalize fetish videos of women trampling small animals to death (“crush videos”). When it was applied in a case of dog-fighting videos (U.S. v. Stevens), the law was struck down for being overly broad, and a narrower law was enacted. The author analyzes underlying legal issues, especially whether animal protection can override free speech rights. Since the new law specifies a state interest in extreme cases of animal cruelty, the author argues that animal protection law was ultimately advanced due to the Stevens case, even though the conviction was thrown out.

[Abstract excerpted from original source.}

“Robert Stevens was indicted for marketing dog-fighting videos in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 48, a law criminalizing depictions of animals being “intentionally mutilated, tortured, wounded, or killed…” The law aimed principally at “crush videos,” but extended to dog-fighting as well. Stevens challenged the law’s constitutionality and the Supreme Court eventually struck it down. This article explores whether the Stevens decision will have lasting implications for animal cruelty jurisprudence. It argues that the answer is “maybe, but probably not.” In Stevens, the Court skirted the question of whether preventing animal cruelty can rise to the level of compelling state interest. Ironically, its avoidance of the issue may constitute a net positive for animal advocacy.”

External Link:
http://works.bepress.com/david_cassuto/5/
Faunalytics
Meet the Author:
Faunalytics is a nonprofit research organization dedicated to helping animals by providing useful information to advocates to help them increase their impact.

Citations:

Cassuto, D. N. (2012). United States v. Stevens: Win, loss, or draw for animals? Journal of Animal Ethics, 2(1), 12–19. doi: 10.5406/janimalethics.2.1.0012

Tags:

Animals Used for Food Animals Used in Science Companion Animals Effective Advocacy Other Topics Animal Cruelty Animal Law Animal Racing English Evaluation Living Conditions Voting Farm Animals Humans Research Animals Wildlife

Related Posts

Ending Cosmetics Testing on Animals in the United States

The report presents findings (broken down by age and gender) on the level of awareness about cosmetics testing on animals, opposition to the practice, and safety concerns.

In the Spotlight

Key Findings from a National Public Opinion Survey on Animal Protection and The Humane Society of the United States

Public attitudes toward animal protection, with emphasis on opinions of The Humane Society of the United States (HSUS) and donors' opinions of The HSUS.

In the Spotlight
dog in field

All About Dogs: Population And Shelter Trends In The United States

The most successful states and localities don't simply require owners to sterilize and license their companions - they provided the resources and services for them to do so easily.

In the Spotlight
a mother and baby chimpanzee reclined against a branch wrapped in rope

Project ChimpCARE: Evaluating the Care, Management, and Welfare of Privately Owned Chimpanzees in the United States

This conference presentation describes the basis and strategy of the work of Project ChimpCARE, a non-partisan group committed to improving the well-being of chimpanzees.

In the Spotlight
backyard poultry being raised for meat

Urban Livestock Ownership And Regulation In The United States

This article discusses the motivations and practises of the increasingly common idea of people to have "urban livestock"

In the Spotlight
pigs with their face pressed up to a dirty cage

Factory Farm Pollution In The United States

This online reference uses information from the U.S. Department of Agriculture to map out factory farms across the country.

In the Spotlight

Infographic: Vegetarianism In The United States

This infographic by Faunalytics details the current state of veg*ns in the U.S. with information on numbers, reasons for their choice and more!

In the Spotlight
cow lying in grass

Economic, Political, And Global Demands On The United States Dairy Industry

The average production rate of milk cows has increased in the U.S. from 1970-1992 and is expected to continue to do so for the future.

In the Spotlight
fish-farm-mountain-background

Shaping Attitudes Toward Aquaculture In The United States

To shape people's opinions about aquaculture, animal advocates should rely on key influencers and focus on environmental messages.

In the Spotlight
aerial view of a factory farm

Major Uses Of Land In The United States, 2007

This report of land use in the U.S. has found that pasture land takes up 27% of U.S. land usage whilst urban usage only takes up 3%.

In the Spotlight
cooked steak in a frying pan

Trends In Meat Consumption In The United States

This article examined the trends, distribution, and potential detriments of meat consumption within the U.S.

In the Spotlight

Fisheries of the United States (2012)

In this annual report covering 2012, the U.S. government estimates that commercial fish "landings" totaled 9.6 billion pounds for the year (fish deaths are measured in pounds, not individual lives). This represented a 2.3% decrease from the previous year (2011). Measured in value, commercial landings in 2012 were estimated to be $5.1 billion, 3.2% lower than in 2011. Recreational fishing accounted for 380 million individual fish being caught in 2012, with 60% of those fish being released, according to survey results.

In the Spotlight
Faunalytics uses cookies to provide necessary site functionality and to help us understand how you use our website. By continuing to use this site, you agree to our privacy policy.
I Agree
meerkat-emails.jpg

Don’t Miss a Thing

Faunalytics delivers the latest and most important information directly to your inbox. Choose what topics you want to see and how often you get our emails, and you can unsubscribe anytime.