Animal Suffering: An Evolutionary Approach
This paper explores the notion of animal suffering, including examining traditional definitions of suffering and attempting to provide a more expansive definition of suffering as the “experience of one’s life going badly.” This includes, but is not limited to, physical pain and negative emotions.
Though much is written about animal suffering, little is said about the nature of suffering itself. Without any clarity about its conceptual nature, discussions concerning detection, prevention and reduction of suffering are seriously hampered. This paper considers – and rejects – some of the more usual understandings of suffering (such as that suffering is synonymous with either pain or negative emotions). Instead, an alternative understanding of suffering is proposed, namely that suffering is the experiencing of one’s life as going badly. This notion is tied to the loss of individuals’ central life projects. It is suggested that non-human animals’ central projects are their evolved survival skills. This alternative view of suffering has major implications for animal welfare.
[Excerpted from report abstract]