Early Risk Factors For Separation-Related Behaviors In Puppies
Separation-related behaviors (SRBs) are problem behaviors, such as barking, chewing, or house soiling, that dogs show when family members are away. As these behaviors can result in destruction of the family home, excessive noise, and concern for the dogs affected, there is value in exploring how these types of behaviors can be prevented from developing altogether. Using the data from the longitudinal study ‘Generation Pup’, researchers aimed to find specific early-life risk factors linked to these behaviors at six months of age. The analysis included 145 puppies in the U.K. and Republic of Ireland, born between March 2017 and November 2018.
Tracking Puppies Through Their First Six Months
In the ‘Generation Pup’ study, family members completed questionnaires about their household habits and new puppy from joining the study, before 16 weeks of age, to six months of age at scheduled intervals. Questions were also presented regarding how family members responded to behavior they wanted to discourage. For the analysis, guardians who reported using two or more aversive techniques, such as telling the puppy off or a physical correction, were compared with those who used fewer.
Puppies counted as showing SRBs if their guardians reported behaviors such as barking, pacing, chewing damage, or house soiling only when the puppy was left alone. By this definition, 68 of the 145 puppies (46.9%) showed SRBs at six months. Pacing was the most common (14.5%).
Overnight Enclosure And Sleep
The results of the study showed an important correlation between overnight experiences and reduced SRBs. Specifically, by 16 weeks of age, puppies who had experience being in a confined space such as a crate or room overnight were less likely to show SRBs at six months. One theory behind these results is that the enclosed space acts as a stepping stone between being with the family and being alone. The authors also note the reverse is possible: guardians may only manage to confine puppies who are less distressed by separation.
Puppies whose guardians said they slept nine or more hours a night at 16 weeks or younger had lower odds of SRBs. The comparison group was puppies who slept six to eight hours. Puppies still having four or more house-training accidents a week at 16 weeks or younger also had higher odds of SRBs than those with three or fewer, though guardians may have counted separation-related soiling among those accidents.
How Guardians Train And Respond To Their Puppies
The study also found that how family members train and respond to their puppies in the first six months was linked to SRBs at six months of age. For example, puppies trained with dog treats or kibble other than their usual food at 16 weeks or younger had higher odds of SRBs. The authors call this result unexpected, say it could be a false positive, and don’t recommend that guardians stop using treats.
Puppies whose guardians used two or more aversive techniques when responding to unwanted behavior at six months had higher odds of SRBs. Time-outs, such as ignoring the puppy or moving them to another part of the house, were also linked to higher odds of SRBs when guardians used them while relaxing at home.
Fussing over the dog (greeting, stroking, cuddling, or playing with them) in response to unwanted behavior on returning home was linked to almost six times the odds of SRBs. Finally, puppies of younger guardians (16 to 34 years old) had higher odds of SRBs than those of guardians 35 and older. The authors suspect age stands in for something they didn’t measure, such as daily routine. Attending puppy classes and the longest time puppies were left alone at six months, along with breed, sex, and where the puppy came from, showed no significant link with SRBs in the final model.
Limits Of Guardian-Reported Data
Of 1,987 dogs in the six-month data, only 145 were analyzed, mostly because of missing data. Most of those dogs (74.5%) were purebred. The small sample meant low statistical power, and with many factors tested, some results may be false positives. Guardians may also miss quiet behaviors, and the questions included behavior on their return, not only during absence.
The difference between causation and correlation should also be noted when examining the results of this study. For example, dogs who sleep more may have lower SRBs, and dogs with lower SRBs may also tend to sleep more because they are more relaxed. Additionally, fussing over the dog may cause increased SRBs, or guardians may fuss over their dogs more when they see SRBs being presented. Finally, the study only followed dogs to six months of age, so it can’t show how SRBs develop later.
What This Means For Advocates
This study suggests there is value in paying particular attention to the first 16 weeks of a dog’s life. Providing a breadth of structured positive experiences to encourage comfortable sleep in a crate or room may be one way family members can support the well-being of their dog early in life. Ensuring that the crate is not a place where the dog feels ignored such as in a ‘time out’ also appears to be relevant to those welcoming a young puppy into their home. The authors also suggest avoiding fussing over puppies in response to unwanted behavior when guardians return home, though fussing could be a response to SRBs rather than a cause.
Trainers and behavior consultants should note that this study adds to evidence against aversive methods, including time-outs, although it found no clear effect of positive reinforcement. As puppies of younger guardians were more likely to show SRBs, veterinarians, adoption agencies, and puppy trainers could pay special attention to younger clientele and ensure they are supported with resources to help them manage SRB development in their puppies, although this finding needs to be replicated. It is important to focus on the welfare of the animal when addressing SRBs, not just reducing the behaviors themselves. The authors stress that their results are exploratory and correlational, and that intervention studies are needed to confirm which prevention strategies work.
https://doi.org/10.1017/awf.2024.56

